Friday, July 29, 2011

SHRM/Globforce Employee Engagement Survey, 2011

While companies are investing in employee recognition, majority lack proactive strategies to increase engagement and retention
Globoforce®, the world’s leading provider of SaaS employee recognition solutions, recently announced the results of the 2011 SHRM/Globoforce Employee Recognition Tracker Survey, a new semi-annual survey on the state of employee engagement and recognition conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM). With responses from more than 700 HR leaders and practitioners, the survey provides critical insight into the current engagement and recognition practices, perspectives, and challenges for today’s leading companies.

'According to the SHRM/Globoforce Employee Recognition Tracker Survey, nearly all HR leaders surveyed (99 percent) anticipate employee engagement being a key challenge they will face, yet non-strategic engagement and recognition programs continue to pervade companies. In fact, while 86 percent of companies track employee engagement scores, a startling 71 percent of those same respondents track engagement levels via employee exit interviews. This means companies are only learning about engagement issues at the time employees voluntarily leave the company. In addition, only 37 percent of HR leaders said they tie employee recognition programs to corporate values while less than half (43 percent) recognize employees based on performance related to the organization’s financial goals. These low percentages indicate an enormous missed opportunity to drive performance and manage culture through a strategic recognition investment.
“The SHRM/Globoforce Employee Recognition Tracker Survey provides HR leaders with key insights into their peers’ engagement and recognition practices and strategies,” said Eric Mosley, CEO of Globoforce. “Our first survey shows companies put engagement at the top of the priority list yet fall short in aligning these programs at the strategic level. Measuring recognition adds a level of accountability for all employees, and is ultimately how behaviors change and culture is actively managed. It’s also how today’s HR leaders can gain the much-needed support and investment from senior management for strategic engagement and recognition programs.”
Key findings from the survey include:
Employee performance and acknowledgement remain disconnected
  • 54 percent of HR leaders do not think managers and supervisors at their company effectively acknowledge and appreciate employees
  • 69 percent believe employees are not satisfied with the level of recognition they receive at work
  • 44 percent of respondents do not think their employees are rewarded according to job performance
  • 42 percent state multi-source (manager, senior leader, peer) ongoing feedback is the most accurate appraisal of employee performance; yet, 61 percent believe annual performance reviews are an accurate appraisal of employees’ work
Engagement remains a priority, yet practices remain passive and reactive-based
  • 86 percent of HR leaders track employee engagement; however, 71 percent said they monitor it in employee’s exit interviews while 65 percent relate it to employee retention rates
  • Differing generations among employees is the top workforce management challenge, with 85 percent calling it “very important” or “important,” followed by multiple cultures (84 percent); harnessing social networking technologies (72 percent); and global diversity (62 percent)
  • Employee engagement is the most critical HR challenge in the next three to five years with 99 percent of HR professionals listing it as “very important” or “important,” followed by culture management (96 percent), employee recruitment (96 percent), and employee retention (95 percent)
Evaluating the success of recognition programs is a black hole for HR leaders and CEOs
  • 87 percent of companies do not currently track the ROI of their recognition program
  • 68 percent said they find it difficult to measure the effectiveness of their recognition program
  • Nearly 1/3 (32 percent) of CEOs invest no time (and may not even be aware of) employee recognition programs
  • 49 percent of responding companies track their programs by unit/department – making it hard for senior management to get a full view of recognition efforts and effectiveness companywide
  • When asked the reasons for the challenge in measuring ROI, the top three were:
    • “Our metrics of success keep changing, making it impossible to consistently report on ROI.” (32 percent)
    • “The recognition program cannot be linked with our talent management or performance management systems, giving us no insight into how recognition affects key metrics such as performance improvement or retention.” (32 percent)
    • “The recognition program is not designed to deliver improvement in metrics that our executive leadership (CEO/CFO/COO/CHRO, etc.) finds valuable.” (22 percent)' 
      ( Source: Reuters)

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Myopic Mantras

Some comments of Mr. Som Mittal President Nasscom and Mr. Rajendra Pawar Chairman Nasscom in the ongoing Nasscom HR Summit -

Mr. Som Mittal: 'The Indian information technology is in need of more ‘specialists' even as the industry is tapping new markets and getting engaged with new global customers...Our colleges produce research students but not specialists in a sector...The number of engineering colleges has nearly doubled to 3,300 from 1,700, and around 6,50,000 graduates enter the job market every year. This number will increase to one lakh in the next couple of years. Graduates should not only be trainable but also employable, then companies would not need to spend 18 weeks on training...The industry annually spends nearly $1.3 billion on training and ‘re-skilling' students, putting enormous pressure on companies' operating costs. “We need to increase the pool of trainable people."

Mr. Rajendra Pawar: "With nearly 3.7 million students getting into higher education each year, the challenge is to make them industry ready as they pass out from the colleges."

Fundamentally I have a difference of opinion on two issues:

a) Generalists versus specialist: Being in business school for little more then 11 years now, I have seen this classical dilemma very closely. What do you expect school to produce? Retail comes and wants students to be retail-specialists, IT comes and they want students to be IT-specialists; likewise every industry expects students to be specialist in that particular industry. This is true for business schools as well as true to a large extent for trade schools. So what do expect school to do? Business schools instead of having specilizations like Marketing, Finance, HR, etc. to have specializations like Finance for IT, Finance for Retail, Finance for Media...
In my opinion  the content that is given to the students in schools has to be largely generalist-content which develops their decision-making abilities and makes them ready to adapt to different conditions and use their knowledge and skills that they have acquired in these schools for finding solutions to various problems that they encounter. Of course' part of their content also needs to be specialist-content with focus on specific industries. But that cannot over-rule the former. Otherwise we run the danger of producing too narrow specialists who do not know what to do once the context changes.

b) Skill-Gap...What skill Gap? - I have been hearing this rant for quite sometime now - 'there is a severe skill-shortage... gaps needs to be plugged...students have to become more employable...schools need to make students more industry-ready.' For sometime I also fell in this 'trap'. However I am of the opinion that there is no real skill-gap ( I am not saying that contemporary skills are not required). All this skill-gap story that we hear is only an attempt by the industry to 'shift' the cost of training to educational institutions. Instead of creating robust employee training infrastructure and facilities, the companies are very conveniently trying to transfer this responsibility (often read as burden) to the schools. And 'skill-gap story' is a convenient way of branding (or say masking) this no-ble strategy.

Both these 'initiatives' are myopic and are going to hit industry hard in the long-run. In today's dynamic and volatile environment, as much you require specialists, the need for strong generalists who can bring in diverse perspectives cannot be discounted. And 'engaging' these talent through development of contemporary skills that acts like a symbiotic-link, helping both the company (in achieving their goals) and the employees (in personal, professional and career development) has to be the direction.

Globally the companies who have made it truly in the big-league have never made any such rants. Instead they have gone ahead with blending talent in their companies and in transforming their companies into 'talent-factory'. Whirlpool has 'Whirlpool Virtual University', Disneyland has 'University of Disneyland', McDonald has 'Hamburger University', Sony, Google, Toyotas of the world have followed the same strategy.

But then another question that needs to be answered is - are we trying to create such institutions in the first place?

Friday, July 22, 2011

Tie them with a Tie

'An online survey conducted among 12,500 people in 24 countries by research firm Ipsos reveals that 66 per cent of workers feel senior managers who run the organisation should always be more ‘dressed up' than their employees. More Indians, than their counterparts across the world, want their senior management to dress ‘smart' or formal, and not casual. The sample included 1,000 Indian respondents...Indians, in particular, do not see casual dressers rising up the ranks, with 64 per cent saying they would not make senior management, and 58 per cent describing casual dressers as ‘slackers'...
Only 27 per cent of respondents from Europe claimed the same...'
No wonder we are still developing country... Read an excellent column by T.C.A. Srinivasa-Raghavan that appeared in Business Line few months back. Here it goes:

Formal's sake?
T.C.A. Srinivasa-Raghavan
When I was 13 years old, I spilt something down the front of my school uniform shirt. The school was an old colonial one, which I was obliged to attend very briefly. So we also had to wear a tie, which I had taken off.
It was while putting it back on that I had my great Newtonian or Archmediean moment. Ties, I concluded, were meant to hide stains.
I was very pleased with this great discovery and went and told the curmudgeonly old Anglo-Indian master about this great moment of truth. But of course he was scathing in his response. “It's to keep you warm, you idiot,” he said.
Many years later, I had to attend a National Day function at an embassy in Delhi. It was late September but the card had said that the dress had to be lounge suit.
So there we were, all the men, resplendent in our lounge suits, sweating like horses on the humid lawns. It was awful.
But the women were all wearing flowing clothes. The Indians were in saris and salwars, and the East Asians were in sarongs, while the European women were in loose flowery skirts. Not just that. The poor men were all in shoes because suits need shoes. They also wore socks, while the women were in chappals and sandals.
It was then that the words of the old Anglo schoolmaster came back to me in all their profundity and I had my Second Newtonian Moment – if layers of clothing such as provided by suits and boots were meant to keep you warm, why were we wearing them in the tropics, that too in summer?
Since that day, which I like to think of as my Day of Deliverance, I have not worn a suit in India, even during Delhi's fairly nippy winter. I wear only khadi bush-shirts, mostly white — which led one young colleague to ask me once if I had only one shirt — and chappals or sandals. My only genuflection to the Delhi winter is a pair of socks.
East Asian explanation
A few weeks ago, I was invited to give a talk to some East Asians in Baroda, which is not a cold place by any reckoning. They were all in dark business suits and at some point during the talk, I said we Asians were great imitators, including in the matter of what we regarded as ‘formal' attire.
One of them, a Vietnamese I think, was sufficiently provoked to say that although he found western formal wear a real imposition, he (and the others) wore it because it made for greater acceptability. I found that appalling but then what does one do with such attitudes?
I wanted to tell them that dignity was a state of mind and acceptance based on clothes — the Japanese and the Koreans have even switched to teaching their children western classical music only — was not really genuine acceptance. But I didn't.
I think as India regains her confidence, Indian men should switch to clothes more suited to our climate. After all, why should girls have all the fun?
(This article was published in the Business Line print edition dated February 26, 2010)




Thursday, July 21, 2011

Stupid Rules

Few days back at a busy traffic crossing at Bangalore when we were waiting for the light to turn green, a traffic warden jumped before our car and asked me to turn-off the engine. I was in the car with my wife and my five-year old kid. I politely gestured to the traffic warden in return, expressing my inability to turn-ff the car engine.However the highly animated traffic warden started gesturing vigorously. I rolled-down the window and explained him that since the AC is on I cannot switch-off the engine and since we all were dust-allergic the possibility of rolling-down the windows on a hot evening in one of the busiest junction where toxic fumes and gases emanating from hundred of vehicles around would be a bad idea. However he was not ready to listen and threatened me of dire consequences, if I did not comply. Then suddenly he took-out his blackberry and took a snap-off my car's number plate. He even suggested to me that mother-earth would not forgive me for my 'grave' sin. He finally forced me to turn-off the engine. By the time we pulled-off the junction, I and my family were quite disturbed by the traffic warden's rude and violent behavior and also thinking of what he might be up to with the snap that he had taken of my car's registration number. Worst he spoilt our memorable evening evening when we were returning from Crossword where my latest book had been listed in the best-seller category.I know some environmental enthusiasts would be jumping-off their seats by now in support of the traffic warden. But I am sorry, i would say these are 'Stupid Rules'. The idea of switching-off the car engines at traffic junction sounds so platonic but the harsh realities of our roads is that you can do that only at the risk of breathing-in ammonia and developing severe allergic infections, lung disorder and in the long-run a shortened life. Rules can never be set in isolation. They have to be set by remaining conscious of the ground realities and have to be practical; not esoteric and ideological which can never be related to.
Then few days back I read that some environment-conscious citizens in Bangalore started a campaign of not allowing the municipal corporation to cut few trees in a area for widening the road. They went and hugged the trees and all that made front-page masala for the local dailies. So this time it was the other way around the citizens were setting the rules. So many would exclaim, how sensitive, how humane. Bullshit! I am sorry for the use of words. But in all probability those who went and hugged the trees are the super-rich  enjoying all the luxuries in their house, adding more carbon-footprints then those poor labours and common man on the street who needs a better road to go to work everyday and earn bread for his/her family.
Some students reportedly went around streets of the city and asked people to stop honking to limit the sound pollution. Fantastic! how philanthropic. However if they had come to me I would tell them go fly a kite. For god's sake, honking saves lives on Indian roads. Bangalore which is the accident capital of India, accounts for 10% of the total accidents that happen in this country, there are some people who are asking people not to honk. In all probability, before sound pollution kills them, a swinging truck or a devilish bus or a erring cab would hit and kill them. And why just Bangalore, this is true of any Indian city. I am sure you all can vouch for it. Pure buffoonery...
In short, rules are only relevant if they are cognizant of the practical issues and the environment in which they are expected to be enforced. And then more stupid rules you have, more people will dissent and find a way around them or desert in frustration. Remember this is true for organizations too. When organizations set rules for their employees they should remember not to make them stupid or become oblivious of the practical ground situation.Such rules would only lead to more and more disengagement.

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Dark Ditch or Smart Pitch

Fear erodes innovation and creativity. Forced choices are only good for getting people to work, not for expecting them to think radically. And without radical thoughts and dissensions without fear, innovation is a distant dream.
An environment that is tempered with fear always stops people for expressing and even if they know that their organization is going the wrong way, they simply keep quiet because they are unsure of the consequences. In an effort to stop their 'boss' falling in a ditch, they may be hurried into the same ditch for speaking their mind. How can one expect people to think creatively in such choked-up environments.
In Microsoft corporation two employees actually wrote memo to Bill Gates telling him that he was wrong on going-on with the strategy of set-top boxes and satellite TV and that the company should instead invest in Internet, which is going to be the next big thing. Bill Gates later called for a meeting and revised the entire strategy. In how many organizations such environments can prevail? Voluntary involvement is at the heart of engagement.
But then, every company has a choice whether to be the Microsoft, Google, Apple of the world or to be a back-office Sweatshop. So choose your way but if you choose the latter then for god's sake stop chanting innovation just because you heard that from somewhere else.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Bubble to thwart trouble

Infosys recently launched 'Infy Bubble', an internal social networking site is supposedly a platform for disgruntled Infoscions to vent on. The site mirrors Facebook and allows employees to connect across borders with colleagues as well as bicker about anything they want.The IT giant seems to be learning its lessons finally. Troubled with a very high attrition-rate (some 7000 odd employees have reportedly left during April-June 2011 period) and unimpressive performance ending quarter June 2011, the wisdom seems to be prevailing finally.

Comparative Financial Performance of TCS and Infosys (quarter ending June 2011)*

TCS
Infosys

Quarter ending June 2011 (figures in Rupees Crore)
Percentage Growth YOY
Quarter ending June 2011 (figures in Rupees Crore)
Percentage Growth YOY
Net Sales
10797.02
31.39%
7485
20.8%
Operating profit
2824.92
25.67%
1952
11.23%
Consolidated Net profit
2414.76
26.69%
1722
15.7%

Total Employees
198614
133560
Attrition Rate
14%
17.5%
*Data are to the closest approximation, based on published open sources.

Not too long back there was a huge issue of infoscions baring their feelings in the social networking sites over the controversial iRACE. At that time the company took a strong exception and went to the extent of introducing a social media rule book to tell employees what they can share and what not on the social media (read my extensive article on this Policing social media isn't a smart policy). However the company has perhaps realized that this way cannot be for long in today era of  competitiveness.
And so this bubble (an attempted internal PR exercise) for a change is expected to thwart the trouble that the company finds itself in today.

Monday, July 18, 2011

Salary-hikes and Engagement

'Employees in India are expected to see a salary hike of 12.9 per cent this year, among the highest in the world, as industries are benefiting from the country's robust economic growth, according to Aon Hewitt.'

Sounds fantastic...Happy time for Indian Employees? Before you jump to conclusions, consider some more facts.
Compensation has long been used by the employers all-over the world to engage and retain people. Ofcourse there has been always a debate as well about the viability of such strategies. For a moment we shall leave all such debate aside. All said and done, money may not be the only or the best engagement tool but that it plays an important role in the same cannot be written-off as well.
But are these hikes really paying-off? Plotting salary-hike data, inflation and GDP growth rate data together over a 10 years period throws-out some interesting perspectives:



a) Above normal salary hikes in Indian Industry Inc. are explained by the high GDP growth rate (green line) that India has witnessed for the couple of years.

b) During the recession period when rate of salary-hikes have fallen sharply, inflation was still rising.

c) In the recovery-phase i.e. post 2009, the inflation line has closely followed the rate at which salary hikes have occurred.

So What?
a) Clearly the benefit of salary-hikes have not been realized in real-terms by the Indian employees because of the high rate of inflation.
b) Companies should keep this in mind while planning hikes and some inflationary adjustments may be required to keep the hikes more relevant.
c) Since there is a serious limitation to the extent that companies can go to adjust rate of hikes, they must seriously start looking at engagement as a holistic strategy rather than  a only compensation-driven strategy.

Popular Posts